The Pelican also features a different pull handle than the Yeti and Ozark coolers as well. I do think the Pelicans pull handle is the lowest on my list of the three. Both offer a limited lifetime warranty, though they mostly just cover manufacturing defects. However, neither company guarantees an identical replacement. The ozark trail canopy Owala reserves the right to replace it with a similar product in stock, and Stanley does not guarantee it will have the same color.
Our journalists combine independent research with (occasionally) over-the-top testing so you can make quick and confident buying decisions. Whether it’s finding great products or discovering helpful advice, we’ll help you get it right (the first time). Stanley’s The IceFlow Flip Straw Tumbler combines the leakproof qualities of a water bottle, the easy-access straw of a tumbler, and the insulating power of a travel mug. Yeti offers seven regular colors, including navy, black, and white, plus a handful of rotating seasonal colors.
The Yeti Rambler has a rugged look, which may appeal to some people. This tumbler has a wider, squatter profile than our other picks. For anyone in the market for a cooler that works and won’t break the bank, I would absolutely take a serious look at what Ozark Trail has to offer.
The Yeti Rambler held 27 ounces of ice for 11 hours and 10 minutes. All three tumblers were filled with the same amount of crushed ice. The amount decided upon was 27 ounces, the capacity of the smallest tumbler (Orca Chaser). I used crushed ice because it filled the tumblers more completely, leaving less room for air gaps.
Like our top pick’s lid, the Everyday Tumbler’s lid screws into the mouth of the cup, creating a watertight seal that doesn’t leak when you knock the tumbler over. And a rubber gasket holds the plastic straw in place, reducing any splashing. Much like our other picks that come with straw lids, the 20-ounce, leakproof Stanley The IceFlow Flip Straw Tumbler has a built-in flip straw, for quick beverage access. But unlike the straws on those other picks, the IceFlow’s straw can be tucked away when it isn’t in use. The tumbler also has an easy-to-grip contoured body and a carrying handle built into the lid (rather than ozark trail canopy jutting from the side), so it fits easily into a backpack’s bottle pocket.
But when this vessel is knocked on its side, it leaks considerably—the press-in lid doesn’t create a secure seal at the mouth of the tumbler. The Rambler currently costs more per ounce of capacity than our other picks, and it includes just one type of lid. If you also would like a straw lid, you’ll have to pay another $10—and that lid doesn’t have a rubber gasket around the straw opening, to keep the straw from sliding around. The lip of the mouthpiece gently slopes, to eliminate any splashing, and the MagSlider port cover smoothly glides open and closed.
When you are out on the water, people often sneak over to grab something from the cooler and may not latch it back up. With a hard plastic latch, you run the risk of brushing by the cooler and hitting your shin, which I have done and is awful. One of my favorite features though is the rubber wheels vs. the hard plastic wheels on the Pelican and Yeti.
I then cut around the design so I could save as much of the vinyl scrap for future use as possible. I created the design using PicMonkey and the Cricut Design Space and cut it out using my Cricut Explore. I was sent my Explore for free (love my job!) but I paid for the vinyl out of my own pocket. Elissa Sanci is a senior staff writer for Wirecutter’s discovery team based ozark trail canopy in Denver. Her byline has appeared in The New York Times, Woman’s Day, Marie Claire, and Good Housekeeping.
You can see from the images below that there was consistent ice melt, however two of the three were better performing. As far as color options go, you can purchase this in one of two colors, Greystone which is the one featured in this article and a lighter grey. The constant color feature among the two are the orange rimmed wheels which I don’t love but, it is not a deal breaker. When it comes to the seal, I was again very impressed by this cooler. Cracking this thing open sounds like you are opening the airlock on a spaceship.
But the Takeya tumbler isn’t dishwasher-safe, and the one-piece lid has too many crevices where dirt and other grime can accumulate. Also, stock is currently very limited, so we’ve reached out to Takeya to confirm whether this model is being updated. But the lid created a weak seal, and it leaked a substantial amount when we knocked the tumbler over. The 24-ounce Corkcicle Cold Cup has flat, easy-to-grip panels along its sides. But the press-in lid doesn’t create a tight enough seal to prevent leakage when the cup is knocked over.